AI Evaluation
Every manuscript submitted to Eonforth undergoes rigorous, multi-dimensional assessment by independent AI evaluators prior to editorial review.
Stage 1: Submission
Authors provide: Manuscript (including author declarations of AI usage) + SI (supporting information).
The system performs formatting, plagiarism, reference, image-integrity and completeness checks.
Stage 2: Independent scientific evaluation
Every manuscript is evaluated across a defined set of scientific dimensions, leading to one of three decisions: Accept, Transfer, or Reject.
Ideas: Science is the flagship journal of the publisher. Manuscripts submitted to Ideas: Science that are scientifically sound but do not meet the journal’s criteria for publication will be transferred to the most appropriate subject-specific journal within the series.
Authors may also submit directly to a subject-specific journal. For these direct submissions, there are only two possible decisions: Accept or Reject.
Significance
Does the work materially advance knowledge?
Originality
What is genuinely new?
Validity
Are the methods/theory scientifically sound?
Evidence alignment
Do results support the conclusions?
Reproducibility
Can the claims be independently tested?
Literature positioning
Is prior work represented accurately?
Presentation
Is the scientific argument clear?
Example Evaluation
Below is an example of an AI evaluation scoring a manuscript across the core dimensions using a 5-point gauge (Low, Weak, Moderate, Strong, High).